When your landlord sits on your security deposit past New York's 14-day deadline, they're not just breaking the law—they're triggering a penalty structure that can cost them double what they tried to keep, plus interest, plus court costs. Most landlords banking on you not knowing this discover too late that their delay transformed a $2,000 obligation into a $5,000+ judgment.
Understanding that delays don't just entitle you to your deposit back but to additional money as penalties is what separates tenants who accept whatever landlords eventually return from those who make landlords pay for their violations.
Not all tenants are entitled to interest, but if you are, it's money your landlord owes you from day one of your tenancy.
New York law creates a dividing line:
Buildings with 6 or more residential units:
Buildings with fewer than 6 units:
Why this distinction exists: Larger buildings are considered more commercial operations with professional management, while smaller properties often have "mom and pop" landlords.
How to count units:
Examples:
For buildings with 6+ units:
The account requirements:
Interest rates:
Landlord's administrative fee:
Example calculation:
Year 1:
Year 2 (if interest compounds):
Over 5-year tenancy:
Two options for landlords:
Option 1: Pay annually
Option 2: Pay at lease end
Most landlords choose end-of-lease payment because it's simpler administratively.
If landlord hasn't paid interest:
Determine building size:
If 6+ units, interest is owed:
Calculate approximate interest:
Demand specific amount: "Building has [X] units. You were required to maintain interest-bearing account. I am owed approximately $[amount] in accumulated interest, which you failed to pay."
How landlords break interest rules:
Never opening interest-bearing account:
Keeping all interest for themselves:
Exceeding 1% administrative fee:
Commingling with non-interest account:
Each of these violations strengthens your case for penalties.
Interest is just the beginning. When landlords violate the law, they face financial penalties designed to punish misconduct and deter future violations.
New York's security deposit law includes teeth:
General Obligations Law § 7-108 states that landlords who violate security deposit requirements are liable for:
1. Actual damages
2. Punitive damages (for willful violations)
Example penalty calculation:
Plus court costs and filing fees.
Not every violation triggers punitive damages. Courts distinguish between mistakes and intentional misconduct.
Willful violations (punitive damages likely):
Knowingly missing 14-day deadline:
Refusing to return deposit without legal basis:
Commingling funds intentionally:
Pattern of violations:
Ignoring demand letters:
Non-willful violations (punitive damages unlikely):
Genuine mistake:
Lack of knowledge:
Good faith attempt to comply:
The standard: Did landlord know or should have known they were violating the law, and did they do it anyway?
Judges have discretion on punitive damages:
Factors courts consider:
Severity of violation:
Landlord's conduct:
Landlord's intent:
Tenant's actions:
Common penalty amounts:
Minor violations, first offense:
Clear 14-day deadline violation, willful:
Egregious violations, repeat offender:
Example scenarios:
Scenario 1: Honest mistake
Scenario 2: Standard violation
Scenario 3: Egregious abuse
Important constraint:
Even if you're entitled to $7,000 in penalties, small claims limits still apply:
Example:
Options if claim exceeds limit:
For most tenants, small claims limits are sufficient because deposits are typically $1,500-$3,000.
Knowing you're entitled is one thing. Actually getting the money requires proper demands.
Include specific claims for interest and penalties:
Interest calculation section:
INTEREST OWED:
The building at [address] contains [number] residential units. Under NY General Obligations Law § 7-108, you were required to maintain my $[amount] security deposit in a separate, interest-bearing New York bank account.
Over my [X]-year tenancy, my deposit should have earned approximately $[amount] in interest, after deducting your permitted 1% administrative fee.
You failed to:
- Maintain an interest-bearing account, AND/OR
- Pay me any interest during my tenancy, AND/OR
- Include interest in deposit return
I am entitled to $[amount] in unpaid interest.
Penalty calculation section:
PUNITIVE DAMAGES FOR WILLFUL VIOLATIONS:
You willfully violated GOL § 7-108 by:
- Failing to return deposit within 14 days (deadline was [date], now [X] days late)
- Failing to provide itemized statement within 14 days
- Failing to maintain separate interest-bearing account
- Ignoring my repeated demands for return
- [List other violations]
These violations were knowing and intentional. You are a professional landlord familiar with these requirements. Your violations were willful.
Under GOL § 7-108, willful violations subject you to punitive damages up to twice the deposit amount. I am entitled to $[up to 2× deposit] in punitive damages.
Total demand:
TOTAL AMOUNT OWED:
Security deposit: $[amount]
Interest: $[amount]
Punitive damages: $[amount]
TOTAL: $[total]
I demand payment of $[total] within 7 days.
Statement of Claim should include:
Amount claimed line:
Amount: $[total including deposit + interest + punitive damages]
Basis of claim (reason) section:
Plaintiff seeks recovery of:
1. Security deposit: $[amount] - Defendant failed to return within 14 days as required by NY GOL § 7-108. Deadline was [date]. Defendant did not return deposit or provide valid itemization. Forfeited all withholding rights.
2. Interest: $[amount] - Building has [X] units. GOL § 7-108 requires interest-bearing account. Defendant failed to maintain proper account and failed to pay interest over [X]-year tenancy.
3. Punitive damages: $[amount up to 2× deposit] - Defendant willfully violated GOL § 7-108 by [list violations]. Knowing and intentional violations entitle Plaintiff to punitive damages under statute.
Total claimed: $[sum]
How to present interest and penalty claims:
Explain interest entitlement: "Your Honor, the building has [X] units, which means the landlord was required by law to keep my deposit in an interest-bearing account and pay me the interest. They never did. Over [X] years, I should have received approximately $[amount] in interest. I have that included in my claim."
Explain punitive damages: "Your Honor, the landlord's violation was willful. They [missed the 14-day deadline by months / ignored my demands / commingled funds / have pattern of doing this]. GOL § 7-108 allows punitive damages up to twice the deposit for willful violations. I'm requesting $[amount] in punitive damages because the landlord knew the law and deliberately violated it."
Evidence to bring:
For interest:
For punitive damages:
Judge will assess:
Be specific in your request: "I'm asking for my $2,000 deposit, $100 in interest, and $4,000 in punitive damages for willful violation, for a total of $6,100."
Work through this step-by-step:
What you're owed: $[deposit amount on lease]
This is your minimum recovery if landlord violated deadline.
Does building have 6+ units?
If yes, calculate:
Years of tenancy: [X]
Deposit amount: $[amount]
Conservative estimate (1% net): $[deposit] × [years] × 0.01 = $[amount]
Moderate estimate (1.5% net): $[deposit] × [years] × 0.015 = $[amount]
Generous estimate (2% net): $[deposit] × [years] × 0.02 = $[amount]
Use conservative or moderate estimate in demand.
Example:
Was violation willful?
Consider:
If willful, claim punitive damages:
Conservative approach (1× deposit): Good for first demand letter, likely to be awarded
Moderate approach (1.5× deposit): For clear willful violations, 45+ days late
Maximum approach (2× deposit): For egregious violations, months late, repeat offender
Example:
Add it all up:
Deposit: $[amount]
Interest (if applicable): $[amount]
Punitive damages: $[amount]
Filing fee (if already paid): $[amount]
────────────────────────────
TOTAL: $[sum]
Check against small claims limit:
Use exact calculated amounts:
Don't be vague ("I want penalties"). Be specific:
Specificity shows:
Seeing how this works in practice:
Facts:
Claim:
Outcome: Likely just get deposit back, no penalties
Facts:
Claim:
Outcome: Likely awarded $4,000-$5,000 (full deposit + interest + substantial punitive)
Facts:
Claim:
Outcome: Likely awarded full $7,625 (egregious willful violation, pattern of abuse)
Facts:
Claim:
Outcome: Likely awarded $3,600-$4,500 (commingling is serious violation even if eventually returned)
Facts:
Claim:
NYC small claims limit: $10,000
Outcome: Awarded maximum $10,000 (capped by jurisdiction limit, but full punitive damages justified)
Maximizing your recovery:
Always claim maximum in demand letter:
In court, be realistic:
Interest matters most:
Example impact:
Always claim interest if building qualifies, even if amount seems small. It's money you're legally owed.
Interest accrues until paid:
Punitive damages:
Optimal timing:
Landlords often settle to avoid full penalties:
Common settlement pattern:
Accepting settlement:
Going to court:
Consider:
Understanding the law's purpose helps you assert these rights:
Penalties exist to deter violations:
Without penalties, landlords would:
With penalties, landlords:
The 2× multiplier is intentional: Makes violations expensive enough that landlords won't risk it.
Violations cause real harm:
When landlord withholds deposit:
Actual damages often exceed deposit:
Punitive damages compensate for:
Penalties make enforcement worthwhile:
Without penalties:
With penalties:
The penalty structure makes the law enforceable by giving tenants financial incentive to pursue violations.
Understanding penalties gives you negotiating power:
In demand letter: "I am entitled to up to $[2× deposit] in punitive damages for your willful violations. This will cost you far more than simply returning my deposit now."
In settlement discussions: "I'm willing to accept the deposit plus interest without seeking full punitive damages if you pay within 7 days."
Pre-court settlement: "My small claims case is filed. You can pay now and avoid a judgment, or I will seek maximum penalties at hearing."
What landlord weighs:
Versus:
Often landlords pay rather than face penalties.
Your knowledge of penalty provisions gives you strong negotiating position.
When your landlord delays returning your security deposit, they're not just inconveniencing you—they're triggering a penalty structure that can double or triple what they owe you. The $2,000 deposit they thought they could keep becomes a $5,000-$6,000 judgment when you factor in interest (if applicable) and punitive damages for willful violations.
Most landlords who violate these laws count on tenants not knowing about interest and penalty provisions. They return deposits only when pressed, or keep them entirely, assuming tenants won't pursue legal action. When you demonstrate knowledge of your right to interest and penalties, landlords suddenly become much more cooperative.
The law is designed to make violations expensive for landlords—expensive enough that returning your deposit immediately is always cheaper than fighting you. Use that leverage. Demand your deposit, calculate the interest, claim the penalties, and make landlords pay for their violations.
Find out if you have a case in 30 seconds →
